CAMBIN Webinar Series 2: Research ethics committees in French-speaking Central and West Africa: experience-sharing on capacity-building efforts and operations
The second edition of the CAMBIN webinar series took place on Tuesday, 23rd February 2024 via Zoom under the theme “Research ethics committees in French-speaking Central and West Africa: experience-sharing on capacity-building efforts and operations .” This webinar was moderated by Dr. Ghislain Mbessa, member of CAMBIN and lecturer at the University of Douala. He welcomed attendees and introduced the speakers.
Dr. Fayiz Mahamat, chairperson of the Comité National de Bioéthiques du Tchad (CNBT) was the first speaker. He started his presentation by mentioning that CHAD has ratified the three UNESCO conventions: Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights (1997) ; International declaration on human genetic data(2003); and the Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights (2005). He added that the National Bioethics Committee of Chad (CNBT) was created in 2010 with the support of UNESCO and is placed under the supervision of the Ministry of Higher Education.
Dr. Fayiz went further to talk on the principal mission of CNBT which is to help the country to warn populations against harmful practices and experiments, and to preserve the environment ; Provide advice to decision-makers on ethical, legal, scientific and social issues relating to research projects research involving human beings; Contribute to the development of guiding principles on Bioethics issues; and Promote public debate, education and awareness in matters of Bioethics. He added that CNBT meets once every quarter and sometimes in an extraordinary meeting upon convocation of the president.
On Capacity building effort, Dr. Fayiz mentioned that the CNBT has benefited from the Assisting Bioethics Committees (ABC) program by UNESCO. On the basis of this program, the committee has benefited from several training seminars. He added that CNBT has also benefitted from the EDTCP funded project – SNECFA hosted by the Cameroon Bioethics Initiative -CAMBIN. He explained that through the SNECFA project, CNBT has taken part in training workshops on health research ethics and has also had the opportunity to exchange and consult with the Health Ethics Committee of Cameroon during a joint workshop that was organized in Cameroon. This joint workshop provided an opportunity for the two committees to draft a joint exchange and collaboration plan. Through the SNECFA project, CNBT has also had the opportunity to participate in online conferences, develop their Standard operating procedures and engage consultants to support them.
On Challenges, he mentioned that even though a budget line has been granted to the CNBT, disbursement remains a challenge. He also mentioned the lack of a law on bioethics; unavailability of members during the different sessions; Gender aspect; Insufficient rolling stock, Lack of a permanent secretariat team; and Lack of monitoring of protocols in the field
He concluded his presentation by sharing some of Opportunities for the CNBT such as the Introduction of a module on Bioethics at universities – the establishment of a specialized Master’s degree in bioethics at the University of N’Djamena, and Capacity building of members in the review of clinical trials
The second speaker was Mme Haidara Aminata Kone, Assistant Permanent Secretary at the Comité National d’Ethique pour la Santé et les Sciences de la Vie (CNESS), Mali. In her presentation she stated that CNESS is a consultative body created under the authority of the Minister of Health by decree n°02-200/PRM of April 22, 2002. The CNESS is a multidisciplinary group made up of 37 members: 03 personalities appointed by the President of the Republic; 04 scientific personalities appointed by the institutions of the republic (General Assembly, Supreme Court, Prime Minister’s Office, High Economic, Social and Cultural Council); 14 from ministries; 2 from associations,; 3 religious congregations; 4 from professional orders, 2 from CIE; 5 research institutions.
On the activities of the committee, she mentioned that this is mainly done through referrals. Referrals to the Committee may be made directly by the President of the Republic, the Prime Minister, senior authorities or any Malian national with the right to do so. The Committee may refer matters to itself by self-referral. She further went on to explain the mission of the CNESS which includes; Examining research protocols in all fields; Issuing opinions on current ethical issues raised by advancements in knowledge in various fields; and Producing recommendations for the management of internal conflicts within public institutions.
On some of the activities carried out by CNESS, Meme Haidara mentioned: Organising of Public conferences to raise awareness on the missions and achievements of CNESS; Attending training workshops on ethics; Attending Local, sub-regional and international conferences on ethical and bioethical issues; and Collaborating with other Regional ethics committees to build capacity.
On the contributions of the SNECFA project in building the capacity of CNESS members, Mme Haidara stated that a partnership agreement was signed on the 26th of June 2021 by Mali to be a part of the SNECFA Project. Through this project, CNESS has taken part in steering committee meetings, has been part of the process for the development and validation of the collaboration plan between Mali’s CNESS and Niger’s CNERS; Registration with IRB and FWA; Elaboration of SOPs; Capacity building and experience sharing between CNEs in Mali and Niger; Registration on Health Research Web Africa
On the impact of the SNECFA project, she mentioned the experience sharing with other regional ethics committees, IRB (IORGOOI 1492) and FWA (FWA00032832 ) registration; the Elaboration and implementation of SOPs; Strengthened communication through different channels (WhatsApp, email, telephone …)
She ended her presentation by sharing some of the opportunities that exist such as a continued partnership with the SNECFA project to strengthen the capacities of the regional ethics committees, Promoting partnership with other RECs; Collaboration and cooperation between French-speaking African Regional Ethics Committee to standardize research and ethics guidelines in West Africa.
The last speaker for the day was Prof. Amadou Oumarou, a Member of Comité National d’Ethique pour la Recherche en Santé (CNERS. ). His presentation focused on the composition and functioning of CNERS, Capacity building efforts received as a result of the SNECFA project and others from other partners; and the major challenges of the Committee. He stated that the CNESS is a committee that is quite recent compared to the other ethics committees and has undergone an institutional evolution, in the sense that at the beginning it was a national ethics consultative council that managed protocols. This was replaced by the current committee, which was created in 2016 and is now composed of 12 members who all come from different disciplines and different sectors of activity like the Ministry of Justice, Ministry of Health, and Universities. Beyond that, some people are from Islamic and Christian associations; and from civil society.
Prof Oumarou went ahead to present the mission of the CNERS, which includes safeguarding the dignity, rights, security, and well-being of those involved in health research; proceeding with an independent, competent, and diligent examination of the ethical aspects of health research involving human beings and data on life; following up the implementation of the protocols that have been examined and making sure that researchers know the rules of deontology; to understand all the ethical problems at the national level and to make proposals to the State to be able to make the necessary decisions.
On the impact of the SNECFA project, he mentioned that the trainings received have been very useful most especially the trainings on health research ethics, and the development of standard operating procedures. He added that the SNECFA project has helped the committee to have its standard operating procedures and has strengthened the capacity of several members through the TRREE online training on health research ethics. The CNERS members also had the opportunity to prepare and share presentations which was a great experience for the members. The committee also as a result of the SNECFA project got to complete their Federal Wide Assurance registration. Prof Oumarou also added that the SNECFA project allowed them to exchange and collaborate with the National Ethics Committee of Mali-CNESS and also travel to Mali to listen and learn from their experiences. He also mentioned some other capacity-strengthening workshops that they benefited from organized by the University of Zaragoza.
On Challenges, he mentioned capacity building which is mainly due to the fact that there were some changes within the CNERS with 50% of the members now being new members. He added that they will have to undergo the same training as the others so as to improve on their operations. He also mentioned many members have not yet completed their TRREE training online training and gotten their certifications. Another challenge he mentioned was the need to share experiences and collaborate with other sub-regional ethics committees. He equally cited the lack of a permanent secretariat for the committee to meet and carry out their activities. As at now, the committee is currently anchored at the level of the Ministry of Health, where they are provided a room to do their activities
A Q&A session followed the presentations and participants asked questions and share comments on some of the points raised by presenters.


Yaoundé, Cameroon – The CNERSH Dissemination workshop organized under the SNECFA project brought together key stakeholders in health research from Cameroon to discuss and disseminate Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for ethical review and the TRREE national supplement.




